“Houston, we have a (consultant) problem.”
The idea that paid consultants are a necessity for a serious political candidate is debatable. Phil Berger – The $13 Miillion Man – lost his March primary race to a guy with a volunteer staff and 0.6% of the money Berger had in his campaign treasury. Congressman Tim Moore – blessed with the paid presence of God-O-Mightee himself Paul Shumaker — lost to a woman with a volunteer staff.
The three biggest losses for the NCGOP on November 3 – the US Senate race, the 1st congressional district, and the 11th congressional district – were all *managed* by high dollar consultants out of DC.
Political consultants Jonathan Felts and Jordan Shaw – *local boys* — had their claws sunk into dozens of the most frustrating losses for the GOP this year. Felts was right there whispering in the ears of Phil Berger and Michael Whatley right up to each of their bitter ends. (Felts, we hear, continues to whisper in the ear of one Ted Budd. It will be interesting to see if that continues through 2028.)
Jordan Shaw, who got his start in politics as Speaker Thom Tillis‘s press secretary, was tied to a good chunk of the NCGOP’s losing congressional incumbents. We hear Jordan was on-scene for Jennifer Balkcom‘s disastrous on-camera interview with Spectrum.
(We also hear he had his hand in the campaigns of Greg Murphy and Laurie Buckhout.)
Having one guy stretched out as a shot-caller on about a dozen campaigns from Murphy-to-Manteo is C-R-A-Z-Y.
Paul Shumaker’s renowned high-dollar sidekick, Dee Stewart, gained fame as the consultant for the one GOP candidate for NC House who managed to lose to an unaffiliated candidate.
All of this losing that still generates big checks to well-connected Raleigh types.
I am told that, once someone gets IDed as a candidate for state-level office, party staff will *gently* steer them to one of HQ’s preferred consultants. Even if you already have one of your own lined up.
You’ll be told that you need to hire one of theirs.
There are many other of these consultants we haven’t named. But one thing is interesting – most of them have W-L records that would certainly not qualify them for post-season bowl games or tournaments if they were sports teams.
Instead of shoving your cronies down candidate throats, why not be more supportive? Why not help prospective candidates vet prospective consultants? Compile and distribute win-loss records and fee schedules. Serve the party membership as opposed to serving the Raleigh-based machine. Does a consultant with a losing overall record really warrant a five- or six-figure fee?
Is a consultant really all that necessary? In some cases, an experienced, knowledgeable operative familiar with the local political landscape works just as well (if not better).
I can see a paid consultant coming in handy for someone running statewide. Fundraising and ad buys can get pretty time-consuming and convoluted. But there is no substitute for having someone embedded at the top of a campaign who KNOWS the local political landscape – who to see, who to avoid, who to advertise with.
Some of the biggest expenses candidates get hit with by these consultants is mailers. They get charged an arm-and-a-leg for producing mailers that a few college kids knowledgeable with Photoshop could knock out instead. The state party can actually help candidates by negotiating mass printing and mailing deals with providers.
In 2015, legislators pulled much of the party’s political ops away from the state party. Proceeds of special interest shakedowns turned into campaign fundraising. Legislative operatives snatched the recruiting of candidates away from local parties. Candidates became dependent on and subservient to the Raleigh political machine. The beast needed to be fed. The cash needed to be hoovered-up. Party leaders and the consultants folks got saddled with became more important than the folks back home.
In the wake of November 3, big change is being called for by the NCGOP base. Now is a perfect time to re-examine and correct a situation that – so far – has done more harm than good in the fight to save North Carolina.






So interesting that I told this consultant in 2024 that Harvey West would be an issue for Laurie in NC1 (her 1st run) and he blew me off. And said Harvey would become “a TV star.” WOW! That was prophetic! West has higher name recognition than either Whatley or Buckhout! Or the mustache