Are public high schools failing our kids?

There’s a thought-provoking report out that suggests just THAT:

I discovered this in an unpublished manuscript at my schoolannual economics conference: “According to Harrigan and Davies, between 1987 to 2007, 90% of the increased comparative value of a college degree came from the declining performance of high schools rather than the increasing performance of colleges; in essence, higher education has become more valuable because high school education has become exceedingly less valuable by comparison.” And that is despite the tripling in per pupil spending, adjusted for inflation, in the last fifty years.

Students and families now need to spend big bucks on higher education to get them just past where they could have been with high school effectiveness at the “Nation at Risk” level of the early 1980’s!

Most of the publicized test score data is for 4th and 8th graders, which prevents widespread recognition of the biggest problem of all; the failure to engage near-adults in high value academics at high rates. While many schools are dysfunctional, the larger problem is that even the schools that are reasonably good at what they do are still not a good fit for a lot of the children trapped there by the public school monopoly on public funding. Ending the officially sanctioned discrimination against students that are a poor fit for the mainstream instructional approaches — school choice on a level playing field between public and private options — is the exit strategy from this expensive, growing disaster.