#ncga SD-25: Lexo strikes back. McInnis, confused. Dallas practicing law without a license. (Film at 11.)
Just four months in front of an election, it sounds like things are not so hunky-dory and lovey-dovey here in the Sandhills:
Demonstrating just how rankled local Republicans still are over the ugly state Senate primary this past spring, defeated challenger Michelle Lexo’s campaign has filed a complaint alleging violations of campaign finance laws by incumbent Sen. Tom McInnis and groups that supported him.
Lydia Boesch, who served as Lexo’s campaign treasurer, detailed the allegations in a July 27 letter to Sheryll Harris, in the campaign finance division with the State Board of Elections. Patrick Gannon, a spokesman for the state board, confirmed that the letter was received Monday.
The allegations will be reviewed, and then a decision made on whether any action is warranted. Action could range from requiring amended campaign finance reports, to levying fines, or turning the matter over to a district attorney’s office for criminal charges.
Boesch’s complaints mainly target McInnis, who lives in Richmond County, and the NC Republican Senatorial Committee (NCRSC) — since renamed the NC Senate Majority Fund. The letter also raises concerns about campaign mailers paid for by the NC Chamber, NC Property Rights Fund, Homebuilders Educational Fund and Mainstreet Merchants for a Better NC.[…]
Need a refresher on all this? Click Here.
MORE:
[…] “It is very clear that Mr. McInnis, the NCRSC, the NC Chamber of Commerce and other organizations cooperated in a concerted, coordinated effort to defeat Ms. Lexo through a relentless assault of mailers that were intended to destroy her character in the eyes of likely primary voters,”
Boesch wrote in the complaint. “The first mailers were relatively calm. The closer to the primary date, the more vitriolic the mailers became, as they contained unfounded, outrageous, unsubstantiated false statements, clearly intended to affect the outcome of this race.”
McInnis, reached by phone Tuesday morning, called the claims “ludicrous” and said there was no coordination. He said he has not seen a copy of Boesch’s letter.
“It sounds like a bunch of sore losers,” McInnis said. “I had no knowledge of anything the NC Chamber, NC Property Rights Fund, Homebuilders Education Fund and Mainstreet Merchants did. My campaign did not coordinate anything with anyone. They did that totally on their own without my knowledge or consent. I have no control over any third-party money that is spent on my campaign or anyone else’s campaign. I don’t know where they (Lexo) are coming from. It is the most ludicrous thing I have heard in my life.”[…]
All of those groups sent out nearly identical mailers in other key General Assembly primaries across the state. That HAD to require some coordination.
MORE:
[…]Dallas Woodhouse, executive director of the state Republican Party, told The Pilot Tuesday afternoon that his organization has reviewed the complaint and “found it to be completely without merit.”
First of all, WHY is the state party weighing in on a legal matter involving two Republican campaigns that does not even mention the state party organization? (Second, WHY is this cartoon character doing said weighing-in?)
MORE:
[…] “We have all the confidence in the world that nothing illegal was done,” he said. “We did not coordinate with anyone. We don’t say what independent groups can do. Nobody has acted in any other way but honorably. … The alleged coordination, there is no proof.”
Woodhouse said many of the things alleged in the complaint are not unlawful in the first place, such as accusing groups of knowingly saying things about Lexo that were untrue. He said it is not up to the state elections board or any government agency to determine the “veracity” of political speech, which is protected by the First Amendment.[…]
So, the cartoon character is defending the practice of LYING??? Also, Dallas does not appear to have been paying attention to the news. Congressman Walter Jones has filed a formal complaint with the state over false statements made by his primary opponent’s campaign. According to the Jones team, there is state statute on the books that says willfully and knowingly saying something false about someone during a campaign is a misdemeanor.
MORE:
[…] “That would be pretty scary for the government to determine what you can say or not say,” he said of political campaigns. “They don’t decide what the truth is. The voters decide that at the ballot box. … We knew from the beginning that this would be a hard-fought race.”[…]
Let’s see. HOW MANY people have you, your grandpa, and Mr. Stark, esq. banned and disavowed from the party over statements they have allegedly made?
MORE:
[…] The NCRSC paid more than $62,000 for 10 mailers for McInnis over the course of the campaign, according to campaign finance reports. McInnis’ campaign repaid $60,000 to the NCRSC before the May 8 primary.
The other four groups spent a combined $72,000 on eight mailers, according to Boesch’s letter: NC Chamber, $29,516 for three mailers; NC Property Rights Fund, $22,748 for three; Homebuilders Educational Fund,
$12,156 for one; and Mainstreet Merchants for a Better NC, $2,720 for one.
“Many of the mailers contained a significant number of false statements about Ms. Lexo,” Boesch wrote. “At no time did any of the organizations contact Ms. Lexo before the mailers were sent to determine if the statements they were publishing were true. Taken together as a whole, these mailers amounted to significant derogatory reports about Ms. Lexo that were intended to affect Ms. Lexo’s chances to win this primary election.”
[…]
“The mailers from NCRSC stated, ‘Paid for by the North Carolina Republican Senatorial Committee and Authorized by McInnis for State Senate,’” Boesch wrote.
“A Moore County resident questioned Mr. McInnis about this ‘Paid for . . .’ designation,” she wrote. “He responded that the NCRSC was ‘loaning’ him money for the mailers. That seemed odd because, if it was a loan, the mailers would have said ‘Paid for by McInnis for State Senate.’”
Boesch included copies of each of the mailers with her letter.
She asserts in her letter that one of the reasons the NCRSC sent the mailers is because it was cheaper that what it would have cost if McInnis’ campaign had mailed them out.
“We have been advised by the owner of Red Dome Consulting that NCRSC had a contract with the U.S. Postal Service that allowed the NCRSC to send the mailers at 10 cents less than it cost Ms. Lexo to send her mailers,” Boesch wrote. “Mr. McInnis derived a benefit from the lower postal rate of the NCRSC. In addition to reporting the cost of the mailers as an in-kind contribution, he also should have reported this differential in postal rates.”
And Red Dome ought to know. They got paid by the NCRSC for “direct mail” at the same time they were representing Michelle Lexo.
MORE:
[…] Boesch alleges that the other reason McInnis had the NCRSC send the mailer “is the value of this perceived endorsement by the Senate Republicans.”
“The ‘Paid for by the North Carolina Republican Senatorial Committee’ designation on the NCRSC mailers unquestionably was viewed as an endorsement of Mr. McInnis by Senate Republicans,” she wrote. “The value of that endorsement also should be computed and reported by Mr. McInnis as an in-kind contribution.”
‘Unlevel Playing Field’
Boesch wrote that McInnis received “substantial benefits” from this agreement through the reduced postal costs the NCRSC paid to send out 10 mailers and through the endorsement McInnis received from the “paid for by NCRSC” on the mailers.
The letter alleges that the NCRSC provided extensive consulting services to and on behalf of Mr. McInnis.
“Those services included, but are limited to, planning strategy, performing opposition research, obtaining polling data, and push-polling,” Boesch wrote. “Ms. Lexo had to pay for those types of consulting services; Mr. McInnis did not. This clearly results in an unlevel playing field. The value of the consulting services the NCRSC provided to Mr. McInnis should be calculated and reported as an in-kind contribution.”
Boesch says in the letter that the NC Chamber and the NC Property Rights Fund “coordinated” with McInnis and the NCRSC. It says both the NC Chamber and the NC Property Rights Fund filed independent expenditure reports.
“It’s our understanding this means they did not ‘coordinate’ with Mr. McInnis or the NCRSC, which acted as a consultant to the McInnis
campaign,” she wrote. “We do not have the authority to investigate the records of any of these organizations, but we strongly suspect that there was significant and ongoing coordination between the McInnis campaign, the NCRSC, the NC Property Rights Fund, and the NC Chamber.[…]
The Senate campaign effort was being run out of the Jones Street office of Jim Blaine — Phil Berger’s chief of staff. Get young Mr. Blaine under oath and I’m sure he can shed a whole lot of light on this ‘coordination’ thing.
MORE:
[…]“The same pictures and similar language are used in the mailers sent by all of these organizations. In addition, the comment made by a Moore
County resident with close connections to Mr. McInnis that this race was ‘going to get ugly’ points to a coordinated plan, set in place early in the campaign, to assault Ms. Lexo’s character through mailers. In fact, negative mailers and media comprised the vast majority of Mr. McInnis’ campaign.”
Boesch added that the timing of the mailers “strongly suggests that someone was coordinating this effort. We suspect it was the NCRSC.”
[…]
Boesch said in the letter that Michelle Lexo wanted to run “a clean campaign, based solely on the merits.” She anticipated that the campaign “could and would focus on Mr. McInnis’ voting record and her position on the issues.”
“Instead, the NCRSC decided as soon as Ms. Lexo filed to run that, if they could not persuade her to withdraw from the race, she would be defeated,” Boesch asserts. “The NCRSC then coordinated with Mr. McInnis, the NC Chamber, the NC Property Rights Fund, the Home Builders Education Fund, Mainstreet Merchants for Better NC, Keep Ag Growing Inc., and possibly other organizations to run a campaign on Mr. McInnis’ behalf that would consist primarily of derogatory reports made with no regard for their truth or falsity, that were intended to destroy Ms. Lexo’s chance of winning in the primary.”
[…]
Mr. Woodhouse is probably one of the State Party officials who called Ms. Lexo to tell her not to run….mostly likely at the request of Mr. Berger. No coordination there!!! Woodhouse must love his job if he buckles every time Berger Inc. tells him to jump. This is all about getting “yes” men elected.
Time to vote for the Democrat to keep this clown out. We will find an HONEST Republican for the next term. We could also find an honest Constitution Party candidate next time which would probably be easier.
Losing one seat held by a mendacious individual won’t hurt anything in the meantime.
Vote Democrat, McInnis deserves nothing less.
Unlike Woodhouse, Mrs. Boesch is a lawyer. I hope her complaint will bear fruit if only to put the elite in Raleigh on notice that their loyal troops dislike being played. McInnis has a real knack for continuing to alienate potential voters – just when I thought I could hold my nose. Oh well, if the Democrat wins, we can probably retake the seat in two years.
Many of us were ashamed of the NCGOP & the Senatorial committee‘s behavior in this campaign. It was clear to us that the good old boys were out to smear Ms. Lexo with these lying, vile mailers. I am grateful for the courage of Lydia Boesch to confront this corruption. We Moore County Women will not be told to shut up and sit down. Hayes, Woodhouse, & McInnis behaved like Democrats & do not represent Republican values. Why they are in leadership roles is beyond me. Are we Republicans sheep, re-electing these creeps time after time? I will not hold my nose & vote for McInnis!
We have our own swamp in Raleigh. Berger and Woodhouse are part of it, and it badly needs to be drained.
Berger is following McConnell’s role in the federal Senate of meddling in local primaries. That needs to be stopped at both levels. McConnell’s meddling has cost the GOP quite a few Senate seats over the years, most recently in Alabama. It looks like Berger may do the same. NEVER BERGER.
Woodhouse regularly sticks his nose into things that a party executor director should NOT.
You are right the executive directors job is to be organization and not political and political statements should be made by the Chairman or the Executive Committee.
The State parties job is to assist the district and county parties to have the tools they need to function successfully over the long term and the state party has failed at this for years
A good executive director that focuses on organization structure and function should be a long term position and exist over multiple different state chairman no matter the politics and this would allow stability in daily operations
The executive director should never be the one quoted in the new stories printed or on TV . people should see the effect of the party structure gaining strength but otherwise the executive director should not be seen
If the legislative caucus is allowed to intervene in primaries, then it is high time to take the muzzle off of country party organizations. What is sauce for the goose should be sauce for the gander. If Raleigh is going to intervene publicly, then county parties need to be able to fight back if necessary. There should be a level playing field.
The county parties should take the initiative to do just that. Rules that apply for one and not another aren’t worth much.
There are things that a county party could and should do when the Raleigh power structure tries to meddle in their local primaries. Have your county pass a resolution blasting Raleigh meddling in your county and hit the media hard with it, locally and in Raleigh, too. You could even go so far as to call for the resignation or removal of Berger in order to increase the likelihood that the media would give it good play. Hammer them for what they are doing, hammer them hard, and keep hammering them. Make them regret they ever meddled in your county.
You can even be proactive if you suspect Raleigh may meddle. Contact Berger’s office before it happens and notify them that if it happens your county will fight back and fight back very hard. Nip it in the bud as Barney Fife used to say.
10/4 Raphael.
Browny Douglas
I did not take lightly writing my letter to the BOE. Several facts tipped it for me: the phone calls to Michelle, Mr. McInnis’ explanation for the NCRSC stamp on the mailers, and the lies. Those who believe in honor-based principles can’t look the other way. I’m being criticized for my letter. To me, the Senate Republicans got this ball rolling. Why they chose to pick on Moore County is beyond me. Is Mr. McInnis really that important to them? They should have known Moore County never put up with this.
This case serves as compelling evidence that our concerns about House Bill 373 were warranted, and it needs to be repealed.
This is exactly what people warned of when David Lewis pushed through that abomination. Now it has happened.
Dishonest Campaign Mcinnis with NCSR involved. Hope they can be charged with FALSEHOODS DISHONEST SENATE REPUBLICAN PARTY!
While this whole mess is an affront to democracy, I am especially upset that, 1) the NCSRC was granted “special rates” from a government agency (the US Postal Service) and 2) Berger’s chief of staff was/is running Republican campaign efforts on the tax payers’ dime. His job is to do the business of the people of NC — not the Republican Party (or ANY party). The NCRSC should be required to hire private consultants to do their business, just as private citizens do. They are called PUBLIC servants for a reason….